Again 6 (!) strategies stopped!
- This topic has 86 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 1 year ago by
.
-
Others on here have had ‘exceeds the number of retries’ so it’s not just me.
Oh boy. I *also* have that !!
But there is always a reason behind it (20+ various). And you now showed ONE reason and tell me that it is always that reason. I don’t believe that, hence :we must be talking passed each other somehow.
Note please : I have always showed those 20+ whatever reasons not only including that reason of the time, but also with the full row of rejections. Each one (each yellow triangle) is one rejection. 10 in a row and – boom.
See screenshot in previous email.My main reason for Rejection is / has always been ‘exceeds the number of retries’ .
One more time : that is no reason as such. The reason is mentioned behind the yellow triangle. That 10 attempts were made to overcome the issue is something else and hardly of importance. But, it tells something about the cause;
If my order is rejected (and the system is killed) because of 10 attempts to wait for the distance of whatever being to close to the price, then something hopes that the distance is made larger, which … after 10 attempts in say 10 seconds, still did not happen. PRT (not IG) is not allowing to wait for this forever, and thus Boom you are out (done so by PRT – not IG).broker can’t determine status of last order’.
That is an entirely different kind of message BECAUSE no re-attempt will be done. Think about this – it is logic. Something is really in error now. This is 100% PRT error because while the broker is slow in responding, PRT can not deal with this slowness. If I (as a human) can’t determine the status of my (order) I run away screaming because I won’t be able to know what to do. Is the order still there ? is it filled ? was it killed ? etc. This does not require re-attempting. Something is wrong, period; no need to wait for a solution.
Would we pay attention, then we can learn from these “situations”. Example : Last Friday I had two of these very errors at the exact same time in two accounts on PRT-IB. So something goes wrong in the communication between PRT and the broker (reason : broker is slow in responding) and PRT announces the dreaded “don’t know last status” and kills your system. Yes, PRT-IB sucks too (almost even more so because it is about the only error on IB and I can’t do a thing about it apart from sending in 200 tickets about this – which I already told about and which I really did prior to AutoTrading with even 100x more emphasis on it now AutoTrading is in order with each few days this problem.More nice (not !!!) on this very error : this already happens when PRT-IB resets at 06:00 – 06:30 my time each morning because IB resets at that moment. If I then coincidentally have a Stop Order (for Take Profit) it’s BOOM again. So my code hence PRT sends in that Stop Order but IB is not there to respond (reset takes 30 secs or so). And you know what ? it was very hard to let this happen with manual trading because when IB resets, ProOrder is taken out of functioning on my screen. Thus, I can not *place* an order (all order labels will disappear from the charts and all order-place buttons the same). But now AutoTrading … you know, that beast which runs on a server somewhere and where my code tells at 06:13:13 to place a Stop Order.
See 2nd attachment for such a “morning failure”. The Order itself ended nicely, but the Stop order was still there – also not good at all.It is not good that PRT sucks on this aspect, but it is killing that nobody is doing a thing about this FOR YEARS (which is now 6 years in my case).
1 user thanked author for this post.
that is no reason as such
Okay I will check behind the yellow triangle each time from now on.
I will check 6 different Systems (re Rejections since Friday) behind the yellow triangle later today and report back, Can’t do now as Grandkids be here in 5 mins from school!!
1 user thanked author for this post.
Re above, I had a Sell and a SellShort with the same conditions, this may have confused PRT.
Nah, that won’t confuse PRT. 🙂 Just the last command (from top to bottom) is the one which counts.
So far I never rain into things ProOrder can’t cope with and fails on. Yeah, having Long and Short Systems on one Instrument like discussed today in the other topic. But then things are being done which the broker can’t cope with and PRT can not communicate over.It is quite convenient to know more than one broker. The one (e.g. IG) shows that things are technically possible, while the other (IB) fails on it. PRT can thus do it (while knowing that PRT may need adaption to either).
Knowing what fails on Manual trading is also very convenient; this tells readily what AutoTrading would fail on just the same (n.b.: I don’t have Manual experience with IG).
1 user thanked author for this post.
Find exclusive trading pro-tools on 
