Compound Ratio Weighted Moving Average

This topic has 16 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 1 year ago by Razz.

Tagged: average, Compound, cora, Moving, ratio, Weighted

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 17 total)

1 2 →

03/05/2023 at 4:27 PM #210933

Johnsteed

As I couldn’t find it yet – is anyone aware that a PRT version of the MA according to the concept described in

https://www.tradingview.com/script/NgLjvBWA-RedK-Compound-Ratio-Moving-Average-CoRa-Wave/

or in an extended form described in

https://www.tradingview.com/script/6uNRzTkr-CoRA-Ribbon-Multiple-Compound-Ratio-Weighted-Moving-Averages/

is available?

Thank you for hints.

Johnsteed

Participant

Topics: 7

Replies: 16

Been thanked: 3 times

03/08/2023 at 7:27 AM #211069

Hi @Johnsteed

I don’t think this indicator is present in PRT, when you have all the data (formulas, screenshots, etc.) you can ask if this indicator can be created or converted…

Participant

Topics: 26

Replies: 1758

Been thanked: 814 times

03/08/2023 at 9:56 AM #211078

Johnsteed

Thank you JS for the feedback. It appears as an interesting concept which has been implemented and sold in other very popular trading platforms already. So far I’ve not more information than being available via the links I shared.

I’m not aware how one could ask for an implementation of the concept. Looking at the formulars I may overkook something, but to me the information appears as being incomplete.

Need to see if and how to move on …

Johnsteed

Participant

Topics: 7

Replies: 16

Been thanked: 3 times

03/08/2023 at 10:24 AM #211080

GraHal

Here is more information – including the code (expand at the bottom) if anybody wants to pursue it further?

Looks a useful and new (to us) moving average?

https://www.tradingview.com/script/NgLjvBWA-RedK-Compound-Ratio-Moving-Average-CoRa-Wave/

GraHal

Participant

Topics: 214

Replies: 8830

Been thanked: 2201 times

03/08/2023 at 2:06 PM #211111

Madrosat

hello Grahal

can you translate the code en prt??

Have a good day

Madrosat

Participant

Topics: 24

Replies: 225

Been thanked: 9 times

03/08/2023 at 7:08 PM #211144

GraHal

No, I am not able to translate the code to PRT, sorry.

If you make it easy (for others) by posting the code on here then I’m sure sombody will have a go?

GraHal

Participant

Topics: 214

Replies: 8830

Been thanked: 2201 times

03/08/2023 at 11:24 PM #211157

Madrosat

Here the code
if somebody have a go
//@version=4
// This source code is subject to the terms of the Mozilla Public License 2.0 at https://mozilla.org/MPL/2.0/
// © RedKTrader

study("Comp_Ratio_MA", shorttitle = "CoRa Wave", overlay = true, resolution ="")

// ======================================================================    
// Compound Ratio Weight MA function
// Compound Ratio Weight is where the weight increases in a "logarithmicly linear" way (i.e., linear when plotted on a log chart) - similar to compound ratio
// the "step ratio" between weights is consistent - that's not the case with linear-weight moving average (WMA), or EMA 
// another advantage is we can significantly reduce the "tail weight" - which is "relatively" large in other MAs and contributes to lag
//
// Compound Weight ratio     r = (A/P)^1/t - 1
// Weight at time t         A = P(1 + r)^t 
//                            = Start_val * (1 + r) ^ index
// Note: index is 0 at the furthest point back -- num periods = length -1
//
f_adj_crwma(source, length, Start_Wt, r_multi) =>
    numerator = 0.0, denom = 0.0, c_weight = 0.0
    //Start_Wt = 1.0    // Start Wight is an input in this version - can also be set to a basic value here.
    End_Wt = length     // use length as initial End Weight to calculate base "r"
    r = pow((End_Wt / Start_Wt),(1 / (length - 1))) - 1
    base = 1 + r * r_multi
    for i = 0 to length -1
        c_weight    := Start_Wt * pow(base,(length - i))
        numerator   := numerator + source[i] * c_weight 
        denom       := denom + c_weight
    numerator / denom    
// ====================================================================== ==   

data        = input(title = "Source",                 type = input.source,      defval = hlc3)
length      = input(title = "length",                 type = input.integer,     defval = 20,  minval = 1)
r_multi     = input(title = "Comp Ratio Multiplier",  type = input.float,       defval = 2.0, minval = 0, step = .1)
smooth      = input(title = "Auto Smoothing",         type = input.bool,        defval = true,                    group = "Smoothing")
man_smooth  = input(title = "Manual Smoothing",       type = input.integer,     defval = 1, minval = 1, step = 1, group = "Smoothing")

s           = smooth ? max(round(sqrt(length)),1) : man_smooth
cora_raw    = f_adj_crwma(data, length, 0.01, r_multi)    
cora_wave   = wma(cora_raw, s)

c_up        = color.new(color.aqua, 0)
c_dn        = color.new(#FF9800   , 0)
cora_up     = cora_wave > cora_wave[1]
plot(cora_wave, title="Adjustible CoRa_Wave", color = cora_up ? c_up : c_dn, linewidth = 3)

Here the code

if somebody have a go

//@version=4

// This source code is subject to the terms of the Mozilla Public License 2.0 at https://mozilla.org/MPL/2.0/

// © RedKTrader

study("Comp_Ratio_MA", shorttitle = "CoRa Wave", overlay = true, resolution ="")

// ======================================================================

// Compound Ratio Weight MA function

// Compound Ratio Weight is where the weight increases in a "logarithmicly linear" way (i.e., linear when plotted on a log chart) - similar to compound ratio

// the "step ratio" between weights is consistent - that's not the case with linear-weight moving average (WMA), or EMA

// another advantage is we can significantly reduce the "tail weight" - which is "relatively" large in other MAs and contributes to lag

// Compound Weight ratio r = (A/P)^1/t - 1

// Weight at time t A = P(1 + r)^t

// = Start_val * (1 + r) ^ index

// Note: index is 0 at the furthest point back -- num periods = length -1

f_adj_crwma(source, length, Start_Wt, r_multi) =>

numerator = 0.0, denom = 0.0, c_weight = 0.0

//Start_Wt = 1.0 // Start Wight is an input in this version - can also be set to a basic value here.

End_Wt = length // use length as initial End Weight to calculate base "r"

r = pow((End_Wt / Start_Wt),(1 / (length - 1))) - 1

base = 1 + r * r_multi

for i = 0 to length -1

c_weight := Start_Wt * pow(base,(length - i))

numerator := numerator + source[i] * c_weight

denom := denom + c_weight

numerator / denom

// ====================================================================== ==

data = input(title = "Source", type = input.source, defval = hlc3)

length = input(title = "length", type = input.integer, defval = 20, minval = 1)

r_multi = input(title = "Comp Ratio Multiplier", type = input.float, defval = 2.0, minval = 0, step = .1)

smooth = input(title = "Auto Smoothing", type = input.bool, defval = true, group = "Smoothing")

man_smooth = input(title = "Manual Smoothing", type = input.integer, defval = 1, minval = 1, step = 1, group = "Smoothing")

s = smooth ? max(round(sqrt(length)),1) : man_smooth

cora_raw = f_adj_crwma(data, length, 0.01, r_multi)

cora_wave = wma(cora_raw, s)

c_up = color.new(color.aqua, 0)

c_dn = color.new(#FF9800 , 0)

cora_up = cora_wave > cora_wave[1]

plot(cora_wave, title="Adjustible CoRa_Wave", color = cora_up ? c_up : c_dn, linewidth = 3)

Madrosat

Participant

Topics: 24

Replies: 225

Been thanked: 9 times

03/11/2023 at 9:08 AM #211349

Madrosat

Hello Nicolas can you translate this code ,ou somebody can make it .
Have a good day

Madrosat

Participant

Topics: 24

Replies: 225

Been thanked: 9 times

03/20/2023 at 9:51 AM #211771

Nicolas

This indicator has been translated, you can download it here: RedK Compound Ratio Moving Average (CoRa_Wave)

3 users thanked author for this post.

Razz,

GraHal,

Johnsteed

Nicolas

Keymaster

Topics: 81

Replies: 20863

Been thanked: 4774 times

03/21/2023 at 10:30 AM #211864

Johnsteed

Hello Nicholas and the forum users having engaged here,

thank you very much for this achievement! Being an infrequent user of the forum, I wasn’t sure how to manage to get this implemented. Great work!

I like to add that the indicator is recommened to be used in multiple-data setup to create bands. These bands are said to provide even more useful information about the market situation and to support trading activities. This is likely to be evaluated yet.

Just as a reminder, I included the link describing the band appeal already in my initial post:

https://www.tradingview.com/script/6uNRzTkr-CoRA-Ribbon-Multiple-Compound-Ratio-Weighted-Moving-Averages/

In the material therein, one finds a comparison with other moving averages. That one might be interesting to those trying to use moving averages to provide trade signals, as CoRA is said have less lag than other moving averages. It is a subject of study to see if CoRA is indeed in a way superior in regards of lower lag while effectively smoothen insignificant price variations in the trend to avoid false trend change signals.

So everyone open to explore new things might see a new action item.

1 user thanked author for this post.

GraHal

Johnsteed

Participant

Topics: 7

Replies: 16

Been thanked: 3 times

03/21/2023 at 1:25 PM #211874

Nicolas

Ok, for the record, just add multiple times the indicator on the price chart in order to form a band (with different length period of course).

1 user thanked author for this post.

Razz

Nicolas

Keymaster

Topics: 81

Replies: 20863

Been thanked: 4774 times

03/22/2023 at 7:13 AM #211903

Razz

Good morning Nicolas Thank you for the indicator . It would be good if the indicator had the 5 lines as in the original and it would be best if a buy and sell signal is displayed if all 5 lines have the same direction/color. Don’t know how to implement that if I insert the indicator 5 times?

Best regards

Razz

Participant

Topics: 30

Replies: 156

Been thanked: 23 times

03/22/2023 at 9:04 AM #211907

Nicolas

Each moving average has its own color following their values comparison, ascending is green, descending is red.

You can CALL multiple times the indicator and check if each of one is ascending or not: CALLMA1>CALLMA1[1]

Create a boolean that check all 5 MA ascending:

buycondition = CALLMA1>CALLMA1[1] and CALLMA2>CALLMA2[1] and ........up to 5

1	buycondition = CALLMA1>CALLMA1[1] and CALLMA2>CALLMA2[1] and ........up to 5

Nicolas

Keymaster

Topics: 81

Replies: 20863

Been thanked: 4774 times

03/22/2023 at 11:06 AM #211917

Razz

Good morning Nicolas Thanks for your answer, but I don’t understand it and it’s beyond my programming skills. If I insert the indicator 5 times, the difference will be changed in the variables (e.g. 20,50,70,90,120). will then probably watch the whole first manually.

Razz

Participant

Topics: 30

Replies: 156

Been thanked: 23 times

03/22/2023 at 11:18 AM #211919

Razz

I’ve tried it like this but it doesn’t show any changes?

Callma1 = CALL "PRC_Adjustible CoRa_Wave"[20, 2, 1, 1](close)
Callma2 = CALL "PRC_Adjustible CoRa_Wave"[50, 2, 1, 1](close)
Callma3 = CALL "PRC_Adjustible CoRa_Wave"[70, 2, 1, 1](close)
Callma4 = CALL "PRC_Adjustible CoRa_Wave"[90, 2, 1, 1](close)
Callma5 = CALL "PRC_Adjustible CoRa_Wave"[120, 2, 1, 1](close)

If  CALLMA1>CALLMA1[1] and CALLMA2>CALLMA2[1] and CALLMA3>CALLMA3[1] and CALLMA4>CALLMA4[1] and CALLMA5>CALLMA5[1] then
buycondition =1
endif

return  buycondition

Callma1 = CALL "PRC_Adjustible CoRa_Wave"[20, 2, 1, 1](close)

Callma2 = CALL "PRC_Adjustible CoRa_Wave"[50, 2, 1, 1](close)

Callma3 = CALL "PRC_Adjustible CoRa_Wave"[70, 2, 1, 1](close)

Callma4 = CALL "PRC_Adjustible CoRa_Wave"[90, 2, 1, 1](close)

Callma5 = CALL "PRC_Adjustible CoRa_Wave"[120, 2, 1, 1](close)

If CALLMA1>CALLMA1[1] and CALLMA2>CALLMA2[1] and CALLMA3>CALLMA3[1] and CALLMA4>CALLMA4[1] and CALLMA5>CALLMA5[1] then

buycondition =1

endif

return buycondition

Razz

Participant

Topics: 30

Replies: 156

Been thanked: 23 times

Author

Posts

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 17 total)

1 2 →

Find exclusive trading pro-tools on