Live trades do not match those of the backtest

Forums › ProRealTime English forum › ProOrder support › Live trades do not match those of the backtest

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 31 total)
1 2 3
  • 06/14/2024 at 12:16 AM #233851
    Tropic

    Sorry guys but I don’t understand much of what you’re talking about. Thank you for your many replies but it seems like you’re going a bit “off topic”.

     

    It seems to me that some of you keep telling me to start the backtest from the date the system is flat or from the moment I started putting the trading system live too, right? I did it and I repeat that in this case it works, the trades in live match with that of the backtest, even if I start it from a slightly earlier date, the problem is when I increase the duration of the backtest, I am interested in the one to 1kk bars, and that’s where it doesn’t work because the last trades that the backtest tells me are totally different from those I had live, I can’t.

    I still can’t publish the code here because it is long and complex and it is not entirely mine so I think it is better to avoid it, but I assure you that the algo instructions are simple and correct and there are no conditions under which the trades it carries out depend on previous trades, from equity, gain or similar things . Furthermore, the trades I had live are almost totally different in every way from those in the backtest, they don’t even come close, different dates, different entry and exit times, longs that should actually be shorts, etc. It seems that they come from another algorithm, it is not clear where it comes from.

    It almost seems that in reality IG does not have the correct data available for 1KK bars of the Nasdaq 1 min but it only holds it for about 50k bars maximum after which the backtest is not more reliable, could this be the problem?

    Thank you

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    avatar inverse
    06/14/2024 at 7:59 AM #233854
    GraHal

    When you have a trade in Live that does not agree with a trade in backtest, was there a trade in backtest already open when the trade in Live executed / opened?

    To assess above, use the most recent trades and post a screenshot(s) so we have something other than guesswork to try and help you.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    avatar inverse
    06/15/2024 at 4:11 AM #233888
    inverse

    @Tropic, apologies for the derailment …. I’d be keen on understanding what you’re seeing (interop processes) so if you could kindly reply to @GraHal perhaps they and others, (yes @PeterSt inclusive because it’s clear from there historical posts that they have been around the block a few times), could then try and nut out what’s going on.

    06/15/2024 at 8:25 AM #233889
    PeterSt

    Th thought slipped into my mind that possibly Tropit is using real Futures and that he backward passes roll over dates. This is not something which shows at first glance; but it would imply quite exactly the effect you’re observing, Tropit.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    avatar inverse
    06/16/2024 at 10:53 AM #233917
    Tropic

    @inverse don’t worry, no problem, just talk about it here if it can help solve the problem.


    @PeterSt     In reality I am using a normal CFD account with IG so I don’t think they are futures, unless IG is doing some hidden trick whereby it replaces Nasdaq CFDs with Futures, I continue to become suspicious of IG’s ability to provide correct data that Now I expect everything.

    @GraHal

    I can’t tell you if the backtest had trades already open while it was doing the live trades, unfortunately I noticed it a little late. Now I’ve stopped it from Live and won’t put it back into action until I fully understand what’s happening.

    I’m sending you here the screen of the backtests that I also sent to IG technical support, maybe it’s a little difficult to see, sorry, you have to open it and zoom in.However, on the left there is the backtest in the period in which I had the system live, the trades all coincide correctly with the live ones.
    On the left is the 1 million bar backtest.

    I have now noticed that among these trades there are also those he made live. But he adds others that he didn’t do live without understanding why.
    Furthermore, I don’t know why during the period in which it was live it did all short trades, but now that I am continuing to test it in a demo account it tends to only do long trades and the 1 million bar backtest continues to not coincide adding other trades that he doesn’t do in the live demo. If needed, I’ll take a screenshot of this too.

    06/16/2024 at 10:59 AM #233918
    Tropic

    My god guys sorry I don’t know why it won’t let me upload the screenshot, is png format supported?

     

    Ok now worked

    06/16/2024 at 11:01 AM #233920
    Tropic
    Tropic wrote:

    @inverse don’t worry, no problem, just talk about it here if it can help solve the problem.


    @PeterSt     In reality I am using a normal CFD account with IG so I don’t think they are futures, unless IG is doing some hidden trick whereby it replaces Nasdaq CFDs with Futures, I continue to become suspicious of IG’s ability to provide correct data that Now I expect everything.

    @GraHal

    I can’t tell you if the backtest had trades already open while it was doing the live trades, unfortunately I noticed it a little late. Now I’ve stopped it from Live and won’t put it back into action until I fully understand what’s happening.

    I’m sending you here the screen of the backtests that I also sent to IG technical support, maybe it’s a little difficult to see, sorry, you have to open it and zoom in.However, on the left there is the backtest in the period in which I had the system live, the trades all coincide correctly with the live ones.

    On the left is the 1 million bar backtest.

    I have now noticed that among these trades there are also those he made live. But he adds others that he didn’t do live without understanding why.

    Furthermore, I don’t know why during the period in which it was live it did all short trades, but now that I am continuing to test it in a demo account it tends to only do long trades and the 1 million bar backtest continues to not coincide adding other trades that he doesn’t do in the live demo. If needed, I’ll take a screenshot of this too.

    i mean “on the right” there is the 1 million barbacktest

    06/16/2024 at 12:59 PM #233937
    GraHal

    Trades in a Table (as you posted above) is not a useful substitue for what I had planned to anlayse your problem.

    If you have the System in your ‘Not Running’ section of ProOrder you can still see the most recent trade that the System and match that date / time with the same date / time in a backtest and then do a screenshot showing both Live and backtest trades.

    When analysing a problem, I work with equity chart + positions and then ‘Cursor Detail’ to view exact price levels and indicator values etc.

    I for you can provide above, I / we may see something that will help you; otherwise, I feel we are going round in circles and getting nowhere?

    06/16/2024 at 1:29 PM #233945
    GraHal
    Tropic wrote:

    But he adds others that he didn’t do live without understanding why.

    I checked again your Table of trades in your screenshot.

    In Live (on the left)  your trades have coincident trades with backtest (on the right).

    In backtest (on the right) you have lots more trades that are NOT coincident with Live (on the left).

    Do you agree with my statements above … simple answer Yes or No and then we can more forward in itterative mode? 🙂

    06/16/2024 at 2:48 PM #233952
    GraHal

    I assume you will answer Yes to my question above?

    So my next question would be … what value for spread have you typed in on the backtest engine settings?

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    avatar PeterSt
    06/17/2024 at 8:47 AM #233983
    Tropic

    Ok thanks, I still have the system in the “not running section” and the trades it tells me are the ones it made in live that I have already sent before, I don’t know if it should also tell me the ones it would have made if I had left it in run, after I stopped it, but I think not because I’m running it in demo and it carries out other trades for me. I’ll send you the screen, tell me if it’s ok or do you need other views.

    Yes, I confirm that the live trades on the left have trades coinciding with the 1 million bar backtest on the right which adds others that do not coincide.

    The spread I used for the backtest is 2 points

    06/17/2024 at 8:58 PM #234015
    GraHal

    Is your backtest using a position size – for some of the trades – that is not allowed in Live?   Result of this would be that some backtest trades match Live but not all backtest trades match Live?

    I am near the end of my guesswork as to the cause of the problem.
    Tropic have you come to any conclusions, ideas or even wild guesses as to the cause?

    Did you buy this Algo off MarketPlace?

    06/18/2024 at 9:29 AM #234029
    GraHal

    Do you get Rejects  in Live where trades in Live do not match trades in Backtest?

    Check Orders List > Cancelled / Rejected tab for above.

    06/18/2024 at 9:38 PM #234069
    Tropic

    Hi Grahal, yes the backtest code uses a fixed position size for all trades of 0.5. If I’m not mistaken the minimum size allowed on the Nasdaq is 0.25 so from this point it seems to cause no problems both in live and in the backtest it puts them all at 0.5 but in the backtest it adds others that aren’t there in live.

    No, I didn’t buy this algo on the Marketplace and I checked the rejected/cancelled orders list and I’m sorry but there doesn’t seem to be any, not even in the period in which it was live.

    I still can’t explain why what happened, apart from my suspicion that IG provides incorrect data in the 1min timeframe, unfortunately I can’t think of any other explainable conclusion for the moment, I’m sorry.

    Another strange thing that I noticed is that the live trades he made noted that they all lasted only “1 number of bars” unlike the backtest ones, as if they were all the same length of 1 minute, but this is not true! Because entry and exit times of the trades in the order list say that in reality they all lasted more than 1 minute and each has a different duration…why this too?

    06/19/2024 at 8:00 PM #234118
    GraHal
    Tropic wrote:

    all lasted more than 1 minute and each has a different duration…why this too?

    Idea … double / treble check to make sure Backtest and Live are both running on 1 min TF.

  • Author
    Posts
Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 31 total)
1 2 3

Find exclusive trading pro-tools on ProRealCode Marketplace

Similar topics:
trades being executes in backtest but not in live autotrading
backtest vs live trade
how do i speed up backtest optimization?
not open more trades for today
v12 for prt-ig now live on live
6 jan 24 prt not available – too long to respond
alert not triggered
alerts not always triggered
atr based stop not working
atr stop not working

Create your free account now and post your request to benefit from the help of the community
Register or Login