One year after

Forums › ProRealTime English forum › ProOrder support › One year after

Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 81 total)
1 2 3 4 5 6
  • 06/11/2018 at 8:34 PM #72938
    Gianluca
    GraHal wrote:

    No, was it all a flash in the pan, a good idea that fell over before it got started??

    Just asking to keep momentum going as we all seemed so enthusiastic at the beginning?

    i am running a lot of strategy in demo since novembre, and some from jan in real, i put on the database asap!

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    avatar GraHal
    03/08/2019 at 11:56 AM #93174
    Meta Signals Pro

    Hi @Francesco,

    I am trying to make this fantastic initiative from Grahal go further, to allow us to select and enhance performing strategies:

    https://www.prorealcode.com/topic/grahals-link-libraries-more/page/3/#post-93038

    Would you enter your performances LIVE (no cash to be shown) in order to grow our global excellence?

    https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1sVas9Tz5gA94nwu-dYWgeGKY1cud7HwvqKkeqjP1aIo/edit#gid=0

    That would be fantastic as you are a key contributor!

    Chris

    03/08/2019 at 11:57 AM #93175
    Meta Signals Pro

    Hi @Verdi,

    I am trying to make this fantastic initiative from Grahal go further, to allow us to select and enhance performing strategies:

    https://www.prorealcode.com/topic/grahals-link-libraries-more/page/3/#post-93038

    Would you enter your performances LIVE (no cash to be shown) in order to grow our global excellence?

    https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1sVas9Tz5gA94nwu-dYWgeGKY1cud7HwvqKkeqjP1aIo/edit#gid=0

    That would be fantastic as you are a key contributor!

    Chris

    03/08/2019 at 12:02 PM #93176
    robertogozzi

    @Kris75, please do not treble+ post the same stuff, even in different topics/forums!

    Moreover, If you need to reference more than one member, you just have to write as many names as you want, each one with a leading AT sign. But.. please… don’t abuse this feature!

    Thank you.

    03/09/2019 at 6:34 PM #93269
    Inertia

    Quick thought …

    In order to motivate people to insert wining strategies in this xls doc in the most efficient way possible, and to create also a bit of challenge and breanstorm within the PRT members, would it be possible for the best strategy to win a prize ?

    Let’s stay a nice Porsche ? Mercedes will do too… Just a thought….;)

    Have a wonderful day !

    03/13/2019 at 9:36 PM #93562
    Meta Signals Pro

    Thanks Roberto; I realised that afterwards which would have spare me some work, but I wanted to be a personal message;

    >> What about contributors contributing to our little sharing strategies performance ? 😉

    03/13/2019 at 9:40 PM #93563
    Meta Signals Pro

    @Inertia you really made me laugh !!!!

    Any other strategies you’re testing by the way ???

    Do you know other plateforms that organize these kind of share, even commercial ones?

    I am in Paris btw and am looking to build a team of motivated proactive and cupid coders 😉

     

    03/13/2019 at 11:20 PM #93568
    Vonasi

    I think that if someone has spent a lot of time and effort on a strategy and then had it patiently on forward test for a year or even just several months and it has proven to perform as well as it did in the back test then it is unlikely that they would be willing to share it to Joe Public just because they were spammed – sorry ‘personally messaged’ on these forums. Unless that is there is a Porsche or Mercedes in the deal as Inertia suggests.

    There are plenty of hints and tips and advice based on solid experience on these forums that if studied, tested and given time will result in your own solid strategies that you probably won’t want to share after all your study and effort.

    Maybe you could just go back through the library and check out the results of all the strategies shared within there and present the OOS results for everyone to check out. There might be a nugget of a strategy but even if there isn’t then your efforts might allow yourself and those who you share the findings with the chance to see what doesn’t work and also maybe improve your and their ability to recognise serious curve fitting?

    Effort = Reward!

    Spamming (sorry ‘Personal Messaging’) = Very little return!

    03/13/2019 at 11:44 PM #93571
    GraHal

    The motivation to post Forward Test performance is that other sharers will see the (already proven profitable) strategy and, with fresh enthusiasm, we spot improvements and so shared strategies become even more profitable?

    I started the Topic below with a straightforward way to log / reference the Auto-Systems but it seems to have gone down lie a lead balloon! 🙂

    https://www.prorealcode.com/topic/forward-test-system-performance-share/

     

     

    03/14/2019 at 12:44 AM #93572
    Meta Signals Pro
    Vonasi wrote:

    Maybe you could just go back through the library and check out the results of all the strategies shared within there and present the OOS results for everyone to check out. There might be a nugget of a strategy but even if there isn’t then your efforts might allow yourself and those who you share the findings with the chance to see what doesn’t work and also maybe improve your and their ability to recognise serious curve fitting?

    Maybe I did it !!! after a year of studying this site on an almost daily basis and this is the first one that really was profitable and stable for me.

    (btw the one I am sharing has been optimised by me)

    Maybe I just wanted to share that! as Prorealcode = “Sharing Proreatime knowledge” if I am not mistaken (or may be we just pretend).

    Maybe I believe in collective intelligence !

    But even if I disagree on the tone of your answer there is something I agree on: it is that this sharing should may not be open to just anyone (this infamous Joe Public just impatiently cupid) ; meaning that some effort = contribution should have been proven on the site to get access to this @graHal 😉

     

    03/14/2019 at 7:07 AM #93581
    Inertia

    @Kris75,

    I am happy to make you laugh Kris75. It is very important ;))

    • Yes I do have 6 others strategies trading live that are my creation built also with “bits and pieces” from this great forum…
    • I do have, perhaps like each and everyone here, more than 40 others working on demo accounts (for a 1 year of incubation’s period or more than 50/100 trades before trading these on live mode).
    • This world wide known magazine may answer your queries: http://traders.com/

    Well sorry Kris75, 2 things..

    • If you do not mind, i will stay in my sunny South of France area where we do have sufficent internet speed to possibly meet our dreams.
    • Secondly, with ALL the respect I owe you, why would I join a team of traders if I do have already profitable strategies ? ;))

    I have to stay that only me and Kris75 have shared ou “working work” so far… were we that naive ?

    Good day all.

     

     

     

    2 users thanked author for this post.
    avatar Meta Signals Pro, avatar Balmora74
    03/14/2019 at 9:40 AM #93589
    Vonasi
    Kris75 wrote:

    But even if I disagree on the tone of your answer

    Sorry if you misread the tone. I was just trying to point out why it is that there is a lack of enthusiasm from everyone to share and discuss their own winning strategies. Personally I don’t share strategies as if I feel something has value from my own effort then I  don’t give it  away for free. I don’t however mind throwing the odd fishing lesson into the forums if I think someone might benefit from it – I just don’t give fish away. I personally have coded many indicators and shared some of them as they might assist someone in creating their own strategies based on their own interpretation of those indicators.

    Generally if a strategy is shared on here by someone it is in its early stages of development and most likely unproven in forward testing. Nicolas tries not to allow obviously curve fitted strategies into the library and so usually they are unproven interesting ideas that make the final cut.

    If you have forward tested all the strategies in the library then it would be great if you could start a topic with screen shots of all the forward test results – that would save everyone else from repeating what you have already worked so hard at as importing, setting charts up for correct time zones etc for each strategy is a lot of work that your results could save everyone else from having to repeat.

    03/14/2019 at 10:21 AM #93600
    GraHal
    Vonasi wrote:

    If you have forward tested all the strategies in the library then it would be great if you could start a topic with screen shots of all the forward test results – that would save everyone else from repeating what you have already worked so hard at as importing, setting charts up for correct time zones etc for each strategy is a lot of work that your results could save everyone else from having to repeat.

    Above is what I am trying to achieve on the Topic below … but on a collective / collaborative basis.

    https://www.prorealcode.com/topic/forward-test-system-performance-share/

    EDIT / PS

    Systems shared do not have to be your best and most sacred / children’s inheritance 🙂 … they could be those already posted (by kind folk) in the Library.

    03/14/2019 at 10:30 AM #93603
    Vonasi
    GraHal wrote:

    Above is what I am trying to achieve on the link below … but on a collective / collaborative basis.

    Unfortunately I think it adds one extra level of form filling which is one extra reason for people to maybe not get involved. Your snippet library is a great idea but I think you have posted 99.9% of the links! Maybe that is why it is generall referred to as ‘GraHal’s Snippet Library’ and not ‘The Snippet Library’!

    In fact I seem to recall that the snippet library was actually my own idea and suggestion! I want my name on it!

    03/14/2019 at 10:50 AM #93606
    GraHal
    Vonasi wrote:

    but I think you have posted 99.9% of the links! Maybe that is why it is generall referred to as ‘GraHal’s Snippet Library’ and not ‘The Snippet Library’!

    Yes I have added the majority, but I do know Nicolas has added links and I’m sure Roberto does when he remembers! 🙂

    Vonasi wrote:

    one extra level of form filling which is one extra reason for people to maybe not get involved.

    If folks saved the link below on their Daily Bookmarks Dashboard then it is a < 10 second job to add a link.

    Snippet Link Library

    Anyway the GraHal hosted spreadsheets are services I can provide to the Community to make up for me not being expert enough at coding to provide life-changing coded Systems.

     

  • Author
    Posts
Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 81 total)
1 2 3 4 5 6

Find exclusive trading pro-tools on ProRealCode Marketplace

Similar topics:
bb trading one long one short on dax 9-17,30
2 trading strategies in one system
atr stop active after reaching a target
bracket orders (signals upon lo&hi of one candle)
buy on next candle after buysignal
cannot get my interactive brokers account back after cancelling prt
chart always switches to 1 day after asset change
code to exit position after 30 bars if long still in profit
continues to buy after a stopploss
fixed chart settings resetting after reboot

Create your free account now and post your request to benefit from the help of the community
Register or Login