Pine script conversion using ChatGPT 4

• 09/18/2023 at 9:36 AM #221191
  LucasBest

  So the code you wrote above is correct or not ?
  ma = undefined
  if srcValue1[lenValue1] >0 then
  ma = sumf/len
  endif

  If UNDEFINED can only be assign once, can we write “ma = undefined” ?
  Or we should write “once ma = undefined” ?

  

  LucasBest

  Participant

  Topics: 16

  Replies: 208

  Been thanked: 72 times
  09/18/2023 at 9:55 AM #221198
  jacquesgermain

  Hello

  in

  //banker increase position with green candle
  IF fundtrend > bullbearline THEN
  DRAWCANDLE(fundtrend, bullbearline, fundtrend, bullbearline) COLOURED(0,255,0) // Green color
  ENDIF

  add

  IF fundtrend > bullbearline and not bankerentry THEN
  DRAWCANDLE(fundtrend, bullbearline, fundtrend, bullbearline) COLOURED(0,255,0) // Green color
  ENDIF

  then the yellow candle will appair …

  

  jacquesgermain

  Participant

  Topics: 3

  Replies: 111

  Been thanked: 44 times
  09/18/2023 at 10:33 AM #221201
  Meta Signals Pro

  Hi @lucasbest

  « Whatever the prompt i use at the begining Chatgpt does a lot of errors, syntax errors and confusion between the different languages »

  If you believe in the power of a leveraging by working with others, can I propose you share the prompt you used?
  So that we can build a step by step translation process that could maybe have better final results?

   

  

  Meta Signals Pro

  Participant

  Topics: 46

  Replies: 322

  Been thanked: 38 times
  09/18/2023 at 10:52 AM #221204
  LucasBest

  I used th prompt of Nicolas first times, and then i tried to feed chatgpt with list of all instructions of probuilder. Now i don”t use any long prompt but just say “can you translate this pine script code to probuilder language ?”.

  Sometimes chatgpt remember what i said and what it did before and do a good job with colors (splitting them in 3 variables) and with function…
  But what i don’t understand is that sometimes chatgpt go completly wrong, using new instructions, like “function(…)” or “x = IF… THEN… EDNDIF” or even “color = RGB(colorR,colorG,colorB)” in the same discussion like if it forget everything (CHATGPT have alzheimer?) we did or said before…

  It is like if probuilder language is not yet anchored in his DNA, it tries to learn but if a prompt makes it doubt about what it learned previously, then it delete all and become dumb! It is very frustrating… as i accept to loose more time helping him because i thought it will become more and more accurate in translating codes from pine script to probuilder, but i can tell after more than 15-20 indicators conversion that it isn’t the case.

  Maybe best way is to use it partilly for the things it does the best and convert the rest alone?

  1 user thanked author for this post.

  Meta Signals Pro

  

  LucasBest

  Participant

  Topics: 16

  Replies: 208

  Been thanked: 72 times
  09/19/2023 at 8:11 AM #221251
  LucasBest

  An other Pine script indicator convrsion.
  Original script here below :
  https://www.tradingview.com/script/y80r44fM-Advanced-GET-Tom-Joseph-s-XTL-DMA-Cloud-Breakout-Signals/

  DMA Cloud & Breakout Signals

  // Advanced GET XTL + DMA Cloud colR1 = 0 colG1 = 135 colB1 = 225 colR2 = 255 colG2 = 0 colB2 = 0 colR3 = 255 colG3 = 255 colB3 = 30 colR4 = 50 colG4 = 125 colB4 = 255 colR5 = 250 colG5 = 0 colB5 = 0 colR6 = 255 colG6 = 255 colB6 = 255 colREntryBull = 0 colGEntryBull = 0 colBEntryBull = 255 colREntryBear = 255 colGEntryBear = 0 colBEntryBear = 0 colRStopBull = 255 colGStopBull = 0 colBStopBull = 0 colRStopBear = 0 colGStopBear = 0 colBStopBear = 255 // Expert Trend Locator (XTL) len = 34 // XTL Period hLmt = 34 // Threshold Value xtlsrc = (high + low + close) / 3 XTL = CCI[len](xtlsrc) bull = XTL > hLmt bear = XTL < -hLmt neutral = (XTL <= hLmt) AND (XTL >= -hLmt) // Colors for bars if bull THEN R = colR1 G = colG1 B = colB1 ELSIF neutral THEN R = colR3 G = colG3 B = colB3 ELSE R = colR2 G = colG2 B = colB2 ENDIF DRAWCANDLE(open,high,low,close) COLOURED(R,G,B) BORDERCOLOR(R,G,B) //Displaced Moving Average (DMA) showdma = 1 // 1 for Yes, 0 for No: Show DMA? malength = 8 // DMA Length displacement = 5 // DMA Displacement DMA1 = Average[malength](low) DMA2 = Average[malength](high) // Colors for DMA if DMA1 > DMA1[1] THEN RR2 = colR4 G2 = colG4 B2 = colB4 ELSIF DMA1 <= DMA1[1] THEN RR2 = colR5 G2 = colG5 B2 = colB5 ELSE RR2 = colR6 G2 = colG6 B2 = colB6 ENDIF IF showdma THEN Drawsegment(barindex-1,DMA1[1],barindex,DMA1) coloured(RR2,G2,B2,100) Drawsegment(barindex-1,DMA2[1],barindex,DMA2) coloured(RR2,G2,B2,100) Colorbetween(DMA1,DMA2,RR2,G2,B2,20) endif // Breakout Bar Entry & Stop showbbar = 1 // 1 for Yes, 0 for No: Show Breakout Bar Signals cont = 0 // 1 for Yes, 0 for No: Levels as Lines // State Determination IF bear THEN state = 0 ELSIF bull THEN state = 1 ELSE state = state[1] ENDIF prevstate = state[1] // Settings for Breakout Bar bbarstop = 0.5 // Stop Loss Ratio bbaentry = 1.5 // Entry Ratio // Target Settings tar1 = 1 // 1 for Yes, 0 for No: Show Target 1 tar2 = 0 // 1 for Yes, 0 for No: Show Target 2 bbartgt1 = 3 // Target Ratio 1 bbartgt2 = 4 // Target Ratio 2 myrange = high - low // Continuous stop, entry, and target levels IF state > prevstate THEN cstop = low - myrange * bbarstop ELSIF state < prevstate THEN cstop = high + myrange * bbarstop ELSE cstop = cstop[1] ENDIF IF state > prevstate THEN centry = low + myrange * bbaentry ELSIF state < prevstate THEN centry = high - myrange * bbaentry ELSE centry = centry[1] ENDIF IF state > prevstate THEN ctgt1 = low + myrange * bbartgt1 ELSIF state < prevstate THEN ctgt1 = high - myrange * bbartgt1 ELSE ctgt1 = ctgt1[1] ENDIF IF state > prevstate THEN ctgt2 = low + myrange * bbartgt2 ELSIF state < prevstate THEN ctgt2 = high - myrange * bbartgt2 ELSE ctgt2 = ctgt2[1] ENDIF // Non-continuous stop, entry, and target levels IF state > prevstate THEN ncstop = low - myrange * bbarstop ELSIF state < prevstate THEN ncstop = high + myrange * bbarstop ELSE ncstop = UNDEFINED ENDIF IF state > prevstate THEN ncentry = low + myrange * bbaentry ELSIF state < prevstate THEN ncentry = high - myrange * bbaentry ELSE ncentry = UNDEFINED ENDIF IF state > prevstate THEN nctgt1 = low + myrange * bbartgt1 ELSIF state < prevstate THEN nctgt1 = high - myrange * bbartgt1 ELSE nctgt1 = UNDEFINED ENDIF IF state > prevstate THEN nctgt2 = low + myrange * bbartgt2 ELSIF state < prevstate THEN nctgt2 = high - myrange * bbartgt2 ELSE nctgt2 = UNDEFINED ENDIF IF cont THEN pstop = cstop pentry = centry ptgt1 = ctgt1 ptgt2 = ctgt2 displ = -1 ELSE pstop = ncstop pentry = ncentry ptgt1 = nctgt1 ptgt2 = nctgt2 displ = 0 ENDIF // Define the colbar variable IF bull THEN colbar = 1 ELSIF bear THEN colbar = 0 ELSE colbar = colbar[1] ENDIF // Define colors for entry and stop IF colbar = 1 THEN REntry = colREntryBull GEntry = colGEntryBull BEntry = colBEntryBull RStop = colRStopBull GStop = colGStopBull BStop = colBStopBull ELSE REntry = colREntryBear GEntry = colGEntryBear BEntry = colBEntryBear RStop = colRStopBear GStop = colGStopBear BStop = colBStopBear ENDIF // Plot Stop IF showbbar then //AND pstop=pstop[1] THEN Drawsegment(barindex, pstop, barindex+5, pstop) style(dottedline,2) coloured(RStop, GStop, BStop,255) ENDIF // Plot Entry IF showbbar then //AND pentry=pentry[1] THEN Drawsegment(barindex, pentry, barindex+5, pentry) style(line,5) coloured(REntry, GEntry, BEntry, 255) ENDIF // Assuming you also want to plot Targets, here's an example for Target 1 (based on ptgt1 variable) Drawsegment(barindex, ptgt1, barindex+5, ptgt1) style(dottedline1,5) coloured("gold",255) Drawsegment(barindex, ptgt2, barindex+5, ptgt2) style(dottedline1,5) coloured("gold",255) Return

  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245

  // Advanced GET XTL + DMA Cloud colR1 = 0 colG1 = 135 colB1 = 225   colR2 = 255 colG2 = 0 colB2 = 0   colR3 = 255 colG3 = 255 colB3 = 30   colR4 = 50 colG4 = 125 colB4 = 255   colR5 = 250 colG5 = 0 colB5 = 0   colR6 = 255 colG6 = 255 colB6 = 255   colREntryBull = 0 colGEntryBull = 0 colBEntryBull = 255   colREntryBear = 255 colGEntryBear = 0 colBEntryBear = 0   colRStopBull = 255 colGStopBull = 0 colBStopBull = 0   colRStopBear = 0 colGStopBear = 0 colBStopBear = 255   // Expert Trend Locator (XTL) len = 34 // XTL Period hLmt = 34 // Threshold Value   xtlsrc = (high + low + close) / 3 XTL = CCI[len](xtlsrc)   bull = XTL > hLmt bear = XTL < -hLmt neutral = (XTL <= hLmt) AND (XTL >= -hLmt)   // Colors for bars if bull THEN R = colR1 G = colG1 B = colB1 ELSIF neutral THEN R = colR3 G = colG3 B = colB3 ELSE R = colR2 G = colG2 B = colB2 ENDIF    DRAWCANDLE(open,high,low,close) COLOURED(R,G,B) BORDERCOLOR(R,G,B)   //Displaced Moving Average (DMA) showdma = 1 // 1 for Yes, 0 for No: Show DMA? malength = 8 // DMA Length displacement = 5 // DMA Displacement   DMA1 = Average[malength](low) DMA2 = Average[malength](high)   // Colors for DMA if DMA1 > DMA1[1] THEN RR2 = colR4 G2 = colG4 B2 = colB4 ELSIF DMA1 <= DMA1[1] THEN RR2 = colR5 G2 = colG5 B2 = colB5 ELSE RR2 = colR6 G2 = colG6 B2 = colB6 ENDIF   IF showdma THEN Drawsegment(barindex-1,DMA1[1],barindex,DMA1) coloured(RR2,G2,B2,100) Drawsegment(barindex-1,DMA2[1],barindex,DMA2) coloured(RR2,G2,B2,100) Colorbetween(DMA1,DMA2,RR2,G2,B2,20) endif   // Breakout Bar Entry & Stop showbbar = 1  // 1 for Yes, 0 for No: Show Breakout Bar Signals cont = 0  // 1 for Yes, 0 for No: Levels as Lines   // State Determination IF bear THEN state = 0 ELSIF bull THEN state = 1 ELSE state = state[1] ENDIF prevstate = state[1]   // Settings for Breakout Bar bbarstop = 0.5  // Stop Loss Ratio bbaentry = 1.5  // Entry Ratio   // Target Settings tar1 = 1  // 1 for Yes, 0 for No: Show Target 1 tar2 = 0  // 1 for Yes, 0 for No: Show Target 2 bbartgt1 = 3  // Target Ratio 1 bbartgt2 = 4  // Target Ratio 2   myrange = high - low   // Continuous stop, entry, and target levels IF state > prevstate THEN cstop = low - myrange * bbarstop ELSIF state < prevstate THEN cstop = high + myrange * bbarstop ELSE cstop = cstop[1] ENDIF   IF state > prevstate THEN centry = low + myrange * bbaentry ELSIF state < prevstate THEN centry = high - myrange * bbaentry ELSE centry = centry[1] ENDIF   IF state > prevstate THEN ctgt1 = low + myrange * bbartgt1 ELSIF state < prevstate THEN ctgt1 = high - myrange * bbartgt1 ELSE ctgt1 = ctgt1[1] ENDIF   IF state > prevstate THEN ctgt2 = low + myrange * bbartgt2 ELSIF state < prevstate THEN ctgt2 = high - myrange * bbartgt2 ELSE ctgt2 = ctgt2[1] ENDIF   // Non-continuous stop, entry, and target levels IF state > prevstate THEN ncstop = low - myrange * bbarstop ELSIF state < prevstate THEN ncstop = high + myrange * bbarstop ELSE ncstop = UNDEFINED ENDIF   IF state > prevstate THEN ncentry = low + myrange * bbaentry ELSIF state < prevstate THEN ncentry = high - myrange * bbaentry ELSE ncentry = UNDEFINED ENDIF   IF state > prevstate THEN nctgt1 = low + myrange * bbartgt1 ELSIF state < prevstate THEN nctgt1 = high - myrange * bbartgt1 ELSE nctgt1 = UNDEFINED ENDIF   IF state > prevstate THEN nctgt2 = low + myrange * bbartgt2 ELSIF state < prevstate THEN nctgt2 = high - myrange * bbartgt2 ELSE nctgt2 = UNDEFINED ENDIF   IF cont THEN pstop = cstop pentry = centry ptgt1 = ctgt1 ptgt2 = ctgt2 displ = -1 ELSE pstop = ncstop pentry = ncentry ptgt1 = nctgt1 ptgt2 = nctgt2 displ = 0 ENDIF   // Define the colbar variable IF bull THEN colbar = 1 ELSIF bear THEN colbar = 0 ELSE colbar = colbar[1] ENDIF   // Define colors for entry and stop IF colbar = 1 THEN REntry = colREntryBull GEntry = colGEntryBull BEntry = colBEntryBull RStop = colRStopBull GStop = colGStopBull BStop = colBStopBull ELSE REntry = colREntryBear GEntry = colGEntryBear BEntry = colBEntryBear RStop = colRStopBear GStop = colGStopBear BStop = colBStopBear ENDIF   // Plot Stop IF showbbar then //AND pstop=pstop[1] THEN Drawsegment(barindex, pstop, barindex+5, pstop) style(dottedline,2) coloured(RStop, GStop, BStop,255) ENDIF   // Plot Entry IF showbbar then //AND pentry=pentry[1] THEN Drawsegment(barindex, pentry, barindex+5, pentry) style(line,5) coloured(REntry, GEntry, BEntry, 255) ENDIF   // Assuming you also want to plot Targets, here's an example for Target 1 (based on ptgt1 variable) Drawsegment(barindex, ptgt1, barindex+5, ptgt1) style(dottedline1,5) coloured("gold",255) Drawsegment(barindex, ptgt2, barindex+5, ptgt2) style(dottedline1,5) coloured("gold",255)   Return

  2 users thanked author for this post.

  GraHal, Meta Signals Pro

  

  LucasBest

  Participant

  Topics: 16

  Replies: 208

  Been thanked: 72 times
  09/19/2023 at 8:49 AM #221255
  Nicolas

  LucasBest wrote:

  If UNDEFINED can only be assign once, can we write “ma = undefined” ? Or we should write “once ma = undefined” ?

  Whatever, it will have the same effect.

   

  1 user thanked author for this post.

  LaMaille

  

  Nicolas

  Keymaster

  Topics: 81

  Replies: 20863

  Been thanked: 4773 times
  09/19/2023 at 8:57 AM #221257
  Nicolas

  What you need to understand with ChatGPT is that generative AI will do everything to satisfy you, even if it means inventing new instructions, as you’ve seen. Since it doesn’t have all the necessary notions to completely translate code from one language to another (here for ProBuilder), it will do its best to help you, even if it means generating code that isn’t compatible. That’s its purpose, that’s why it was created.
  When ChatGPT tells you that you should talk to someone more accustomed to doing translations, rather than him, it’s again not to disappoint you, it’s a bit like his “soul” talking to you. I also think he detects your insistence and annoyance in the prompt you used at the time 🙂

  *** Thanks again for sharing the indicators you’ve translated, it’s a lot of effort to help the community and I really appreciate it! ***

  

  Nicolas

  Keymaster

  Topics: 81

  Replies: 20863

  Been thanked: 4773 times
  09/19/2023 at 9:13 AM #221258
  Meta Signals Pro

  Hi @LucasBest,

  you see this answer right?

  https://www.prorealcode.com/topic/create-strategies-codes-with-chatgpt-for-prorealtime/page/4/#post-217866

  Are you using GPT4?

  1 user thanked author for this post.

  LaMaille

  

  Meta Signals Pro

  Participant

  Topics: 46

  Replies: 322

  Been thanked: 38 times
  09/19/2023 at 11:39 AM #221266
  supertiti

  a Lucasbest

  Would it be possible to create the “L3 Banker fund flow osci” indicator in the form of a curve (moving average type) that would be applied directly to the price graph.
  Thanks for sharing.

  

  supertiti

  Participant

  Topics: 123

  Replies: 738

  Been thanked: 76 times
  09/19/2023 at 1:08 PM #221275
  LaMaille

  Nicolas wrote:

  I also think he detects your insistence and annoyance in the prompt you used at the time 🙂

  *** Thanks again for sharing the indicators you’ve translated, it’s a lot of effort to help the community and I really appreciate it! ***

  It’s true, I admit I’ve been a little hard on him sometimes and even called him a dumb once or twice… 😳

  No problem for helping the community. I learned a lot here too, and still learning every day.

  

  LaMaille

  Participant

  Topics: 1

  Replies: 18

  Been thanked: 12 times
  09/19/2023 at 1:13 PM #221276
  LaMaille

  Meta Signals Pro wrote:

  Hi @LucasBest,

  you see this answer right?

  https://www.prorealcode.com/topic/create-strategies-codes-with-chatgpt-for-prorealtime/page/4/#post-217866

  Are you using GPT4?

  Just saw it. I have same issue after few hours of using it…
  It is v4 yes.

  

  LaMaille

  Participant

  Topics: 1

  Replies: 18

  Been thanked: 12 times
  09/19/2023 at 1:25 PM #221277
  LaMaille

  supertiti wrote:

  a Lucasbest

  Would it be possible to create the “L3 Banker fund flow osci” indicator in the form of a curve (moving average type) that would be applied directly to the price graph.

  Thanks for sharing.

  From same author, there is this swing indicator on price :
  https://www.tradingview.com/script/ZkAray4F/

  Is that what you want ?

  

  LaMaille

  Participant

  Topics: 1

  Replies: 18

  Been thanked: 12 times
  09/19/2023 at 1:50 PM #221278
  supertiti

  a La Maille

  This Banker swing code is interesting, showing the yellow candles.
  But a curve would be the best.
  thank for your post

  Can anyone translate the swing?

  

  supertiti

  Participant

  Topics: 123

  Replies: 738

  Been thanked: 76 times
  09/21/2023 at 7:21 AM #221361
  LucasBest

  For those who have tradingview and can try those 2 indicators below, which one is the best/more accurate ?
  https://fr.tradingview.com/script/CapG3ivf-Bjorgum-Key-Levels/
  https://fr.tradingview.com/script/iOrhpIqc-Support-and-Resistance-Signals-MTF-LuxAlgo/

  Both do almost the same work, both are long and hard to convert… Can you vote and tell me which one worth to be translated more than th other ?

  

  LucasBest

  Participant

  Topics: 16

  Replies: 208

  Been thanked: 72 times
  09/21/2023 at 11:35 AM #221382
  supertiti

  to Lucas,

  I’m sorry, but the last two indicators you suggested don’t appeal to me.
  The one that catches my eye, on the other hand, is the Banker Fund Swing. Translated into a curve, it would be the best, and in colours identical to the candlesticks, it would be impossible.
  But the impossible is impossible.
  Nicolas might be able to help you with that.
  Thanks for your help.
  Have a nice day.

  

  supertiti

  Participant

  Topics: 123

  Replies: 738

  Been thanked: 76 times
• Author
  Posts