Strategies stopped due to rejected orders – lack of info

Forums ProRealTime English forum ProRealTime platform support Strategies stopped due to rejected orders – lack of info

Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 124 total)
  • #97352

    One good thing about these orphan trades (vs the last load a week or two back) is that I can close orphans via both the Old & New IG Platforms!

    EDIT / PS

    Looks like the Reject Issue might just have cleared as I just had one order executed!

    Same here,

    I had problems all morning with rejected orders. The good thing is that I can close them from the IG platform. In any case, it is frustrating not knowing if this is just the DEMO account or it will happen the same on the REAL account.

     

    #97354

    Today was a total mess.

    8 strategies blocked due to rejected orders (demo Ig).

     

    After restart, now they are stuck in that way since several minutes.

     

    There is no way I will put real money on this platform.

     

    #97358

    it is frustrating not knowing if this is just the DEMO account or it will happen the same on the REAL account.

    All the reports so far seem to be on demo and not real live accounts. We all know that IG do not give much priority to demo. We all also know that this is a major mistake by them because we all use the demo platform to build our confidence and our trading skills. There is a direct correlation between our ability to be good at trading along with our confidence in the platform and the the amount of trading we are then willing to go live with. Every time that a demo strategy is stopped due to IG rejecting orders it is a direct hit on IG’s own bottom line but it seems that they have not given this any priority. I personally had 21 reasons not to go live today and dozens more reasons on top of that over the last few weeks.

     

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #97363

    If anyone could confirm that NONE of this is happening in REAL accounts, I would feel much better knowing that this is just IG neglecting DEMO accounts vs REAL accounts.

    But, if there is no certainty that this will NOT happen in REAL, as Vonasi said, it undermines our confidence in the binomial IG/PRT

    #97364

    Still not sorted is it?

    I’ve had below off and on all day … Stopping … which is unusual when market is open?

    #97367

    I imagine that with these sort of issues there is very little that PRT can do. They simply send our demo orders to IG and IG reject them and our systems all stop. PRT will be reading this (we hope) and probably as annoyed about what is happening as we all are. I imagine PRT don’t reply to this thread as nothing they can say on here will help the situation. Someone at PRT we hope will be communicating with IG directly about all these stopped demo strategies but maybe they just get the same ‘demo is low priority for IG’ reply that we do!

    Obviously all of the above is just guess work as we can only work with the evidence that we have – which is that PRT send demo orders, the orders are rejected by IG, PRT simulate in demo what would happen in a live strategy if you sent 11 orders and they were all rejected by IG.  We wake up on a Monday morning and have to restart 21 strategies and decide that this week is not the week to go live with any of them as the risk is too high and our forward testing results are all messed up to the point where analysing them is worthless.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #97368

    My demo bots have also been stopping and rejecting orders all day.

    My live bots have been working fine.

    So it does seem to be a demo only problem (although I don’t have all demo bots running in live, only some).

    On the whole I find the live system to be way, way more reliable than demo. Not perfect, but usable in my opinion, with issues being quite rare.

    You just have to make sure you monitor everything closely and nip any problems in the bud straight away.

     

     

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #97369

    On the whole I find the live system to be way, way more reliable than demo. Not perfect, but usable in my opinion, with issues being quite rare.

    Thanks for those two sentences that might just give other traders just a tiny bit of confidence to go live with strategies. If only the demo worked exactly the same as the live then just think how many demo traders would not be put off switching to live. IG are you reading this because I think the problem might be at your end of things rather than PRT’s or ours and it is costing you customers?

    #97373

    our forward testing results are all messed up to the point where analysing them is worthless.

    Totally agree, I feel like giving up altogether! I’ve had near 100 Rejects in all with nearly as many orphans spawned.

    I’ve still got about 10 orphans on one account from 2 weeks ago …can’t do anything with them.

    #97375

    our forward testing results are all messed up to the point where analysing them is worthless.

    Totally agree, I feel like giving up altogether! I’ve had near 100 Rejects in all with nearly as many orphans spawned.

    It’s that scrolling back down (after restart) that gets me, what does it achieve?? If we are stuck with this Reject madness then maybe PRT could make it easier to restart Systems PLEASE??

    I’ve still got about 10 orphans on one account from 2 weeks ago …can’t do anything with them.

    #97380

    Just a few seconds ago all my struggling algos from yesterday terminated and the trading report was updated correctly on the DEMO account.

    Looks like DEMO environment had a huge backlog of data / processes to handle these days.

    Now let’s keep fingers crossed that we will have a smooth trading day on DEMO today.

     

     

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #97384

    FYI: 6 minutes after they opened trades, 2 of my demo bots have been stopped. The trades have no stops or limits either. The same bots on live have worked fine – stops & limits in place, and they are still running…

    2 users thanked author for this post.
    #97387

    I’ve closed all open positions on all accounts via the IG PLatform.

    I will close all Systems later this morning and delete all Systems where Gain in Detail Report <> Gain under  Running Systems … so performance history makes sense from a restart of all Systems.

    I hope to start tomorrow / 1 May with a clean slate and make some good out of this whole sorry mess!!

    #97389

    That’s it done … ALL Systems stopped, I’ve got nothing running at all now … I’m FREE AT LAST!!!! 🙂

    I may even have a complete break for at least 1 month and see how I feel!

    I might go back to investing instead!

    #97390

    I might go back to investing instead!

    Careful! The SP500 has made a new all time high this week. Timing is everything when investing but I still couldn’t tell you whether this is the start of a rally or a correction about to happen!

Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 124 total)

Create your free account now and post your request to benefit from the help of the community
Register or Login